Here are some insights that often catch new leaders by surprise, with wisdom from Scripture:
The loneliness is real. You can’t always share your concerns or doubts with your team, and the dynamics with former peers change once you’re their manager. King David felt lonely many times and cried out to God for comfort. Decision-making responsibility can feel isolating, especially when dealing with confidential personnel or business issues. Like the shepherds in Scripture, you’ll sometimes need to watch over the flock while others sleep.
You can’t please everyone, and trying will make you ineffective. Every decision will disappoint someone. Even Jesus said, “Woe to you when everyone speaks well of you, for that is how their ancestors treated the false prophets” (Luke 6:26). You’ll give feedback people don’t want to hear, make calls that benefit some team members over others, and set boundaries that frustrate people. Learning to be okay with this—while maintaining integrity—is essential.
Most of your time goes to things you didn’t expect. You’ll spend far more time on communication, conflict resolution, and administrative work than you imagined. The actual “work” you were promoted for becomes smaller. Remember that when Moses tried to judge every dispute himself, his father-in-law Jethro wisely told him he’d wear himself out—leadership requires delegation and prioritization.
Your team’s problems become your problems. Their mistakes, their conflicts, their personal struggles that affect work—you’re now involved in all of it. “Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ.” You can’t just focus on your own performance anymore.
Being liked and being respected are different things. Early leaders often prioritize being liked because it feels good and seems easier. But Proverbs reminds us that “faithful are the wounds of a friend.” Respect comes from consistency, fairness, clear standards, and following through even when it’s uncomfortable.
You need to actively manage up, not just down. Your relationship with your own leadership matters enormously. Even Paul submitted to the Jerusalem council and sought their blessing. They need to understand your team’s challenges, constraints, and wins. Advocating for your team while managing expectations requires constant attention.
Giving feedback is harder than receiving it. Even positive feedback can feel awkward at first. Critical feedback, especially when someone isn’t self-aware, can be genuinely difficult. “Speaking the truth in love” is a simple phrase that captures a lifelong challenge—honesty delivered with genuine care for someone’s growth.
You’ll need wisdom beyond your own understanding. James wrote, “If any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask God, who gives generously to all without reproach.” The humility to recognize you don’t have all the answers, combined with the courage to lead anyway, is what sustainable leadership requires.
What aspect of leadership are you most curious about or concerned with?
Leave a Reply